Head-to-head · 2026
Middlebury College vs Saint Michael's College
Compare average net price ($31,483 at Middlebury College; $25,239 at Saint Michael's College), ROI score (6.06 vs 6.07), school-wide ten-year median earnings ($76,310 vs $61,317), and admissions selectivity (10.8% acceptance at Middlebury College; 84.5% at Saint Michael's College) using federal College Scorecard data. The table keeps affordability, outcomes, access and program fit separate rather than declaring one universal winner.
Face to face
Metric-by-metric comparison
13 metrics, side by side. Color marks a useful directional signal; admissions, SAT, tuition eligibility, ownership and enrollment stay neutral.
| Metric | Middlebury College | Saint Michael's College |
|---|---|---|
| ROI score (school-wide) | 6.06 | 6.07 ✓ |
| Avg net price | $31,483 | $25,239 ✓ |
| 4-year avg net price | $125,932 | $100,956 ✓ |
| In-state tuition | $67,600 | $51,450 |
| Out-of-state tuition | $67,600 | $51,450 |
| School-wide earnings (10y) | $76,310 ✓ | $61,317 |
| Acceptance rate | 10.8% | 84.5% |
| Graduation rate | 91.4% ✓ | 72.8% |
| Retention rate | 93.7% ✓ | 79.9% |
| Median debt | $13,857 ✓ | $26,922 |
| Enrollment | 2,738 | 1,092 |
| Ownership | Private Non-Profit | Private Non-Profit |
| Avg SAT | 1508 | 1245 |
Cost by family income
Reported net price by income band
Federal averages for students receiving Title IV aid. These are context, not a substitute for either school's financial-aid offer.
| Income band | Middlebury College | Saint Michael's College |
|---|---|---|
| Family income $0–30k | $12,723 ✓ | $12,825 |
| Family income $30–48k | $8,229 ✓ | $9,940 |
| Family income $48–75k | $17,510 ✓ | $18,384 |
| Family income $75–110k | $18,526 ✓ | $26,586 |
| Family income $110k+ | $49,824 | $34,539 ✓ |
Program fit
Shared fields with reported awards
Award share is the share of reported credentials in a field, not the share of currently enrolled students.
| Shared field | Middlebury College | Saint Michael's College |
|---|---|---|
| Economics | 11% | 2.8% |
| Natural Resources Conservation and Research | 6.1% | 7% |
| English Language and Literature, General | 8.7% | 4% |
| Biology, General | 3.4% | 8.4% |
| Neurobiology and Neurosciences | 4.7% | 2.2% |
| Political Science and Government | 4.5% | 2.4% |
| Romance Languages, Literatures, and Linguistics | 5.9% | 0.9% |
| International Relations and National Security Studies | 4.8% | 1.8% |
Decision readout
What the differences mean
Saint Michael's College reports the lower average net price by $6,244 per year. Holding today's averages constant, that is a $24,976 difference over four years ($100,956 vs $125,932).
Middlebury College reports $14,993 higher school-wide median earnings ten years after entry ($76,310 vs $61,317). This is not earnings for a specific major.
First-year retention is 93.7% at Middlebury College and 79.9% at Saint Michael's College. Median federal debt among completers is $13,857 vs $26,922, respectively.
8 of the strongest shared fields with positive award-share data are listed below. Award share describes reported credentials in a field, not the percentage of currently enrolled students.
Keep comparing
Related college comparisons
Promoted matchups involving the same colleges or other leading schools in their states.
Frequently asked
Middlebury College vs Saint Michael's College, answered
4 of the most common questions, with real numbers from federal data.
Which school costs less after aid?
Saint Michael's College is cheaper — average net price $25,239 per year vs $31,483 at Middlebury College. The annual difference of $6,244 adds up to about $24,976 over four years.
Which school reports higher earnings?
Middlebury College reports higher school-wide median earnings ten years after entry: $76,310 vs $61,317 at Saint Michael's College. The gap in the federal data is $14,993. This is not major-specific earnings.
Which school is harder to get into?
Middlebury College is more selective at 10.8% acceptance vs 84.5% at Saint Michael's College.
Is there an overall winner?
No single metric makes either school the universal winner. Compare your actual aid offers, residency tuition, intended major, graduation and retention rates, debt, location and campus fit. EduGradify keeps these trade-offs separate instead of combining admissions selectivity and test scores into a final verdict.